BarkBox vs Chewy
A detailed head-to-head comparison of BarkBox and Chewy based on our 100-point scoring system.
Winner
BarkBox
BarkBox Monthly Dog Subscription Box
83/100
Very Good4.5
26,500 reviews
Chewy
Chewy Online Pet Supply Store
80/100
Very Good4.8
58,000 reviews
Side-by-Side Comparison
Metric
BarkBox
Chewy
Overall Score
83/100
80/100
Price
$29.00
$0.00
Customer Rating
4.5/5
4.8/5
Review Count
26,500
58,000
Best For
Best Dog Subscription Box
Best Online Pet Retailer
About Page
Yes
Yes
Contact Info
Yes
Yes
BarkBox — Score Breakdown
Ingredient Quality15/20
Effectiveness & Results15/20
Safety & Testing12/15
Price vs Value14/15
Veterinary Endorsement6/10
Pet Owner Reviews12/10
Brand Transparency9/10
Chewy — Score Breakdown
Ingredient Quality14/20
Effectiveness & Results14/20
Safety & Testing12/15
Price vs Value15/15
Veterinary Endorsement6/10
Pet Owner Reviews11/10
Brand Transparency8/10
Pros & Cons
BarkBox
Proprietary in-house toy designs deliver genuine novelty each month — a meaningful differentiator over services that source from generic wholesale catalogs.
Treat allergy customization and the toy replacement guarantee address the two most common subscriber pain points in the subscription box category.
Competitive pricing at $23–$35 per month for five to six items represents strong per-item value given the exclusive toy designs and treat quality.
Primarily entertainment and treat-focused rather than nutrition or health-driven, making it a lower-priority spend for owners managing pet health budgets carefully.
Toy quality and theme relevance can be inconsistent month to month, and the subjective nature of themed design means occasional boxes may not resonate with all subscribers.
Super Chewer upgrade adds cost and is almost necessary for large or powerful breeds, reducing the base-plan value case for that segment.
Chewy
AutoShip discounts of up to 35% on first orders provide genuine long-term savings on the products most pet owners buy repeatedly every month.
24/7 customer service with an industry-leading reputation for proactive resolution — including free replacements and personalized gestures that no other major pet retailer matches.
Integrated pharmacy and telehealth services consolidate pet healthcare purchasing into a single platform, reducing the friction of managing multiple vendor accounts.
As a retailer, Chewy does not manufacture or formulate products — so the platform score reflects service and curation quality, not proprietary product excellence.
AutoShip pricing and free shipping threshold can lead to over-ordering for owners of small pets, increasing the risk of product expiration before use.
Private-label American Journey products are competitively priced but do not match the formulation depth or transparency of premium brands like Nom Nom or Ollie.
Our Verdict
BarkBox comes out ahead with a score of 83/100 compared to 80/100. BarkBox is best for best dog subscription box. However, Chewy may be a better fit if you prioritize best online pet retailer.
Pet products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease in animals. Always consult your veterinarian before introducing new products to your pet's routine.